Information on rights of shareholders and shareholders compensation claims ("squeeze-out", mergers, control agreements, delisting of shares etc.), appraisal arbitrage litigation
04 October 2021
Statement from Davidson Kempner regarding the Deutsche Wohnen takeover offer by Vonovia
Vonovia and Deutsche Wohnen Have Circumvented Shareholder Rights
Vonovia launched an opportunistic bid for Deutsche Wohnen and offered key members of the Management Board of Deutsche Wohnen (the "Target Board") attractive roles in the enlarged company. The Target Board has subsequently taken a number of initiatives that are unprecedented and legally questionable, with the sole purpose of helping Vonovia acquire control in the face of shareholder resistance to the offer terms.
Despite the majority of Deutsche Wohnen shareholders rejecting the original offer, the Target Board agreed an amended offer very quickly with a minimum adjustment to the offer terms. Recognising the risk that the amended offer would be rejected once again, the Target Board also included a number of measures to ensure Vonovia's success:
i. Providing Vonovia with almost ~10% of Deutsche Wohnen shares via:
a. The sale of 3.53% of treasury shares for €52/share (below the takeover offer of €53/share)
b. The sale of a further 0.93% of treasury shares at €53/share
c. The issuance of primary shares amounting to 5.17% on a fully diluted basis
ii. Agreeing to waive all conditions, which forces many shareholders to sell or tender their shares as the takeover is effectively considered as "over" prior to Vonovia even acquiring the majority support of Deutsche Wohnen shareholders. The Board has effectively handed control to Vonovia and worked around its own shareholders.
In aggregate, these measures have severely undermined shareholder rights and in particular, their prerogative to decide on takeover offers. Against a background of the conflicts of interest of certain Deutsche Wohnen Board members, this makes the situation even more disturbing and raises serious corporate governance concerns in the German market.
This is a Dangerous Precedent for German Corporate Governance
Vonovia and Deutsche Wohnen have demonstrated that as long as the Management and Supervisory Boards of both companies want a deal to come together, shareholders' opinions and voting rights can largely be cast aside. This creates a dangerous precedent in Germany, in which Management Boards can effectively decide the fate of a company and undermine shareholder democracy.
There is now a serious threat that Vonovia makes a delisting offer for Deutsche Wohnen, a large DAX company with a significant free float. A delisting provides no meaningful benefit to Deutsche Wohnen and it effectively forces many public shareholders to sell or tender their Deutsche Wohnen shares and enable Vonovia to increase its control. Many market observers and German institutions saw this aggressive measure used in the Rocket Internet delisting offer in 2020, another situation marred by material corporate governance failures.
01 October 2021
HOLIDAYCHECK GROUP AG PLANS DELISTING, CONCLUSION OF DELISTING AGREEMENT
Munich, Germany, 29 September 2021, 16:09 CET – The Management Board of HolidayCheck Group AG (ISIN DE0005495329) has today resolved to seek the removal of the company’s shares (delisting) from trading on the Regulated Market of the Frankfurt Stock Exchange (Frankfurter Wertpapierbörse – FWB®) in accordance with Section 39, paragraph 2 of the German Stock Exchange Act (Börsengesetz – BörsG).
At a joint meeting today, the Management Board obtained the approval of the Supervisory Board to enter into an agreement regarding the delisting process with Burda Digital SE, which holds an interest of approximately 73 percent in the company. In the agreement, Burda Digital SE undertakes to make an offer to shareholders of the company to buy their shares at a cash offer price of EUR 2.70 per share. Burda Digital SE believes that the offer price will be above the volume-weighted six-month average price required by law for a delisting purchase offer. The final price will be determined by the German Federal Financial Supervisory Authority (BaFin) and may differ from the estimated amount. As a delisting purchase offer, the offer will not be subject to conditions.
The company has undertaken to apply for the removal of its shares from trading on the Regulated Market of the Frankfurt Stock Exchange during the acceptance period for the delisting purchase offer and will comment on the delisting acquisition offer within the scope of the legal requirements of Section 27 of the German Securities Takeover Act (WpÜG).
The Management Board of the Frankfurt Stock Exchange will make the decision on the delisting. The Management Board assumes that, in line with the rules and regulations of the Frankfurt Stock Exchange, the delisting will become effective three trading days after it is announced, which should be immediately after the decision is made. After the delisting becomes effective, the shares of HolidayCheck Group AG will no longer be admitted to trading or be traded on a regulated market of a stock exchange in Germany or a comparable market in another country, nor will the company apply for or consent to admission of the shares to unofficial (open) markets.
About HolidayCheck Group AG:
HolidayCheck Group AG (ISIN DE005495329), Munich, Germany, is one of Europe’s leading digital firms for holidaymakers. With a total workforce of around 300, HolidayCheck Group AG comprises HolidayCheck AG (which operates hotel review and travel booking portals by the same name), HC Touristik GmbH (which operates the tour operator HolidayCheck Reisen), Driveboo AG (which operates the car rental portals MietwagenCheck and Driveboo). HolidayCheck Group’s vision is to become the world’s most holidaymaker-friendly company in the world.
01 September 2021
Joint Reasoned Statement of Deutsche Wohnen SE: Executive Board and Supervisory Board of Deutsche Wohnen recommend shareholders to accept new, improved takeover offer by Vonovia
Berlin, 31.08.2021 | Press release
NOT FOR RELEASE, PUBLICATION OR DISTRIBUTION (IN WHOLE OR IN PART) IN, INTO OR FROM ANY JURISDICTION WHERE TO DO SO WOULD CONSTITUTE A VIOLATION OF THE RELEVANT LAWS OF SUCH JURISDICTION.
- Offered consideration of 53 euros per share is fair and adequate taking into account all relevant key figures
- Offer provides shareholders the opportunity for a secure, timely and fair realization of value
- Takeover offer of Vonovia is in the best interest of Deutsche Wohnen and all stakeholders
The Executive Board and Supervisory Board of Deutsche Wohnen SE ("Deutsche Wohnen") today published a joint reasoned statement on the new, improved voluntary public takeover offer by Vonovia SE ("Vonovia") pursuant to Section 27 of the German Securities Acquisition and Takeover Act (Wertpapiererwerbs- und Übernahmegesetz – WpÜG). In this statement, both boards conclude that the takeover offer by Vonovia is in the best interest of Deutsche Wohnen, its shareholders and stakeholders. The Executive Board and Supervisory Board have thoroughly analyzed the adequacy of the offer and have taken into account both the strategic benefit as well as the consideration offered. Based on this analysis, the Executive Board and Supervisory Board consider the offer price of 53 euros per Deutsche Wohnen share offered by Vonovia as fair and adequate. Both boards therefore recommend shareholders to accept the new, improved offer by Vonovia.
The Executive Board and Supervisory Board of Deutsche Wohnen have independently examined the conditions of the offer and taken into account fairness opinions provided by five financial advisors. The takeover offer by Vonovia provides shareholders of Deutsche Wohnen the opportunity for a secure, timely and fair realization of value. For the evaluation, the Executive Board and Supervisory Board examined, among other things, the premium on the Deutsche Wohnen share price and compared it with historical premiums in the industry. Both boards have also set the offer price in relation to the price targets by financial analysts and have taken into account the current EPRA NTA. The cash offer of 53 euros per Deutsche Wohnen share is 17.8 percent above the closing price of the Deutsche Wohnen share on May 21, 2021, and 24.8 percent above the volume-weighted average price of the Deutsche Wohnen share during the last three months up to May 21, 2021, the last trading day prior to the publication of the decision by Vonovia to submit the first offer takeover offer. It also has to be taken into account that shareholders received a dividend of 1.03 euros per share following the announcement of the original offer. Based on the offer price and the FFO I expected for Deutsche Wohnen in 2021, there is an implied FFO return of around 2.9 percent and thus a valuation which is around 2 percentage points higher than that of major listed competitors. Furthermore, the offer price is above the average of the price targets published by financial analysts for the Deutsche Wohnen share prior to May 24, 2021. Additionally, the offer price is above the EPRA NTA per share as reported on June 30, 2021.
Deutsche Wohnen also welcomes the strategic benefits of the combination and the resulting added value for all parties involved and stakeholders. With its size and setup, the combined company can set new standards in Europe and play a beneficial role in shaping the future of the industry. Climate protection, needs-based housing and affordable housing are social challenges that require substantial investment and can be better shouldered together. A strong and reliable player can act responsibly in the regulated environment of the real estate market and in the interests of all stakeholders, while at the same time pursuing the sustainable development of the company.
Shareholders are able to accept Vonovia's offer and tender their shares via their custodian bank since the publication of the offer document on August 23, 2021. The acceptance period is expected to end on September 20, 2021, at 24:00 CEST. The success of the offer is conditional upon reaching a minimum acceptance threshold of at least around 50 percent of the Deutsche Wohnen shares issued at the time of the expiry of the acceptance period as well as the fulfilment of other customary closing conditions. The detailed terms and conditions of the offer as well as the closing conditions can be found in the Offer Document of Vonovia.
The Joint Reasoned Statement of the Executive Board and Supervisory Board of Deutsche Wohnen on the voluntary takeover offer (cash offer) of Vonovia to the shareholders of Deutsche Wohnen published on August 23, 2021, is available free of charge at Deutsche Wohnen SE, Investor Relations, Mecklenburgische Straße 57, 14197 Berlin (phone: +49 (0)30 89786-5413, fax: +49 (0)30 89786-5419; email: ir(at)deutsche-wohnen.com).
In addition, the Statement has been published on Deutsche Wohnen’s website ir.deutsche-wohnen.com (in the section “Takeover Offer of Vonovia SE”). The Statement and any additions and/or additional statements on possible amendments to the Takeover Offer are published in German and in a non-binding English translation. Only the German versions are authoritative.
Important Notice
This announcement is for information purposes only and neither constitutes an invitation to sell, nor an offer to purchase, securities of Deutsche Wohnen SE. The terms and further provisions regarding the public takeover offer can be found in the Offer Document. Investors in, and holders of, securities of Deutsche Wohnen SE are strongly recommended to read the offer document and all announcements in connection with the public takeover offer as soon as they are published, since they contain or will contain important information.
The offer will be made exclusively under the laws of the Federal Republic of Germany, especially under the German Securities Acquisition and Takeover Act (Wertpapiererwerbs- und Übernahmegesetz – WpÜG), and certain provisions of the securities laws of the United States of America applicable to cross-border tender offers. The offer will not be executed according to the provisions of jurisdictions other than those of the Federal Republic of Germany or the United States of America (to the extent applicable). (...)
Upcoming appraisal proceedings in Germany
ARENDTS ANWÄLTE will represent minority shareholders in following proceedings:
- ADLER Real Estate AG: DA (with ADO Group S.A, formerly ADO Properties S.A., as dominating party) or squeeze-out
- AMIRA Verwaltungs Aktiengesellschaft: squeeze-out
- ADVA Optical Networking SE
- AKASOL AG: merger squeeze-out
- Allgemeine Gold- und Silberscheideanstalt Aktiengesellschaft (Agosi): merger squeeze-out in favor of Umicore
- AMIRA Verwaltungs Aktiengesellschaft: merger squeeze-out
- Aves One AG
- ERLUS Aktiengesellschaft: squeeze-out
- HELLA GmbH & Co. KGaA
- HumanOptics AG: merger squeeze-out
- i:FAO Aktiengesellschaft: merger squeeze-out
- ISRA VISION PARSYTEC AG: squeeze-out
- KUKA AG
- MAN SE: merger squeeze-ou
- MyHammer Holding AG: merger or squeeze-out
- Nymphenburg Immobilien Aktiengesellschaft: merger squeeze-out
- Odeon Film AG: merger squeeze-out
- RIB Software SE: squeeze-out
- Sachsenmilch Aktiengesellschaft: squeeze-out
- SAINT-GOBAIN ISOVER G+H Aktiengesellschaft: squeeze-out
- Schaltbau Holding AG: DPLTA
- Sport1 Medien AG (formerly: Constantin Medien AG): squeeze-out
- Tele Columbus AG
- VTG AG: squeeze-out
- WCM Beteiligungs- und Grundbesitz-Aktiengesellschaft
- WESTGRUND Aktiengesellschaft: squeeze-out
Adler Pelzer Group decided to launch VTO and DTO for STS Group
Hagen, Germany, 29 June 2021
Adler Pelzer Group decided on June 29, 2021 to make a voluntary public takeover offer (VTO, Voluntary Tender Offer) to all shareholders of STS Group AG for the acquisition of all ordinary bearer shares in STS Group (ISIN: DE000A1TNU68).
The Bidder plans to launch the Takeover Offer as a compensation offer as required for the delisting of the STS Group Shares (DTO, Delisting Tender Offer) from trading on the regulated market of the Frankfurt Stock Exchange (Frankfurter Wertpapierbörse) (Section 39 para. 2 and para. 3 of the German Stock Exchange Act (Börsengesetz)).
The offer document (in German and a non-binding English translation) containing the detailed terms and conditions of the Takeover Offer, as well as further information relating thereto, will be published by the Bidder following permission by the German Federal Financial Supervisory Authority (Bundesanstalt für Finanzdienstleistungsaufsicht) on the internet at http://www.adler-pelzer-offer.com.
The Takeover Offer will be made on and subject to the terms and conditions to be set out in the offer document.
31 August 2021
ADTRAN and ADVA Announce Combination to Create Global, Scaled End-to-End Fiber Networking Solutions Leader
TRATON successfully completes merger squeeze-out of MAN SE
Munich, August 31, 2021 – Today, the transfer resolution of the Annual General Meeting of MAN SE that took place on June 29, 2021 — which stipulates the transfer of shares held by the remaining shareholders of MAN SE to TRATON SE against payment of an appropriate cash com-pensation — has been entered in the commercial register of TRATON SE.
The merger of MAN SE with TRATON SE was also registered at the same time, so that all shares held by minority shareholders have now been transferred to TRATON SE.
The merger between MAN SE and TRATON SE became effective at the same time, with MAN SE ceasing to exist as a legal entity. This means that TRATON SE has successfully completed the merger squeeze-out of MAN SE.
As a result of this merger, MAN Truck & Bus SE and Scania AB, in particular, will become wholly owned direct subsidiaries of TRATON SE. This enables TRATON to make the overall structure of the Group even more efficient, implement decisions more quickly, and reduce administrative ex-penses.
The cash compensation was set at €70.68 per common and preferred share and will be paid out in the next few days.
MAN SE shares will be delisted shortly.
13 August 2021
BaFin clears Vonovia for prompt public takeover offer to Deutsche Wohnen shareholders
zooplus enters into an Investment Agreement with Hellman & Friedman to fully capture long-term growth opportunities
• With Hellman & Friedman as a strategic and financial partner, zooplus gains additional sector expertise, hands-on support, enhanced financial flexibility and a stable ownership structure to fully seize the long-term growth opportunity in the fast-evolving European pet market
Founded in 1984, Hellman & Friedman is one of the oldest and most experienced private equity investment firms operating today. H&F’s distinctive investment approach is focused on large-scale equity investments in high-quality growth businesses in developed markets, primarily in the U.S. and Europe, across growth-oriented sectors. H&F seeks to partner with world-class management teams where its deep sector expertise, long-term orientation and collaborative partnership approach enable companies to flourish. H&F has successfully partnered with companies including in the internet & media and consumer & retail sectors such as Action, Autoscout24, Axel Springer, DoubleClick, Grocery Outlet, ProSiebenSat.1, Scout24, SimpliSafe and Verisure.
Company profile:
04 August 2021
AKASOL AG: Request of the majority shareholder to execute a merger squeeze-out
Darmstadt, August 3, 2021 - Yesterday, the Management Board of AKASOL AG ("AKASOL"; ISIN DE000A2JNWZ9) received the formal request of ABBA BidCo AG with its registered office in Frankfurt am Main ("ABBA BidCo") pursuant to section 62 para. 1 and para. 5 sentence 1 UmwG in conjunction with sections 327a et seq. AktG, to execute the procedure for the transfer of the shares of the minority shareholders of AKASOL to ABBA BidCo in their capacity as majority shareholder in return for an adequate cash compensation in connection with a merger of AKASOL into ABBA BidCo by absorption (so-called "merger squeeze-out") and, for this purpose, to have the general meeting of AKASOL resolve on the transfer of the shares of the minority shareholders of AKASOL to ABBA BidCo within three months upon conclusion of the merger agreement. The merger agreement will contain a statement pursuant to § 62 para. 5 sentence 2 UmwG, according to which an exclusion of the minority shareholders of AKASOL as the transferring legal entity shall take place in connection with the merger. The amount of the adequate cash compensation that ABBA BidCo will grant to the remaining shareholders of AKASOL for the transfer of the shares will be communicated by ABBA BidCo at a later date.
According to its own information, ABBA BidCo holds 5,634,459 shares in AKASOL. This corresponds to a stake of approximately 92.94 percent of AKASOL's share capital. ABBA BidCo is therefore the main shareholder within the meaning of § 62 para. 1 and para. 5 sentence 1 UmwG.
The effectiveness of the merger squeeze-out is still subject to the approving resolution of the general meeting of AKASOL and the registration of the transfer resolution and the merger in the commercial register of the registered office of AKASOL respectively ABBA BidCo.
AKASOL will put the requested transfer resolution on the agenda of the next extraordinary general meeting.
17 July 2021
SOF-11 Klimt CAI S.a.r.l. ("BidCo"), a controlled affiliate of Starwood Capital Group, announces the final result of the Public Takeover Offer for CA Immobilien Anlagen AG ("CA Immo")
06 July 2021
Schneider Electric Investment AG submits request for transfer of the shares of the minority shareholders of RIB Software SE (squeeze out under stock corporation law)
Stuttgart, Germany, 5 July 2021. Today Schneider Electric Investment AG, Düsseldorf, submitted the formal request pursuant to Section 327a para. 1 sentence 1 of the German Stock Corporation Act (AktG) to RIB Software SE that the General Meeting of RIB Software SE shall resolve to transfer the shares of the remaining shareholders (minority shareholders) to Schneider Electric Investment AG for an appropriate cash compensation (so-called squeeze out under stock corporation law).
Schneider Electric Investment AG holds approximately 96.41% of the registered share capital of RIB Software SE and is therefore its main shareholder within the meaning of section 327a para. 1 sentence 1 AktG. The resolution on the transfer shall be passed at an extraordinary General Meeting of RIB Software SE which is supposed to take place in the fourth quarter of 2021. The amount of the appropriate cash compensation that Schneider Electric Investment AG, as the main shareholder, will pay to the minority shareholders of RIB Software SE for the transfer of the shares has not yet been determined.
24 June 2021
Vonovia SE: Vonovia launches public takeover offer for Deutsche Wohnen shares
NOT FOR RELEASE, PUBLICATION OR DISTRIBUTION (IN WHOLE OR IN PART) IN, INTO OR FROM ANY OTHER JURISDICTION WHERE TO DO SO WOULD VIOLATE THE LAWS OF SUCH JURISDICTION.
- Deutsche Wohnen shareholders can tender their shares from today up to 21 July 2021 (24:00 CEST)
Vonovia SE: Business Combination Agreement; Offer for all outstanding shares in Deutsche Wohnen SE
NOT FOR RELEASE, PUBLICATION OR DISTRIBUTION (IN WHOLE OR IN PART) IN, INTO OR FROM ANY OTHER JURISDICTION WHERE TO DO SO WOULD VIOLATE THE LAWS OF SUCH JURISDICTION
ams AG: ams OSRAM announces successful delisting offer and forthcoming delisting of OSRAM shares
- Delisting offer acceptance period ended on 18 June 2021 at 24:00 CEST
- Settlement of Delisting Offer expected for 30 June 2021
Premstätten, Austria (23 June 2021) -- ams OSRAM (SIX: AMS), a global leader in optical solutions, announces the results of the public delisting offer (“Delisting Offer”) in the context of the forthcoming delisting of OSRAM Licht AG (“OSRAM”) following the end of the four week acceptance period of the Delisting Offer on 18 June 2021 at 24:00 CEST.
At the end of the acceptance period, 6,935,319 OSRAM shares had been tendered into the Delisting Offer. This corresponds to approximately 7.2% of shares in OSRAM. Including the OSRAM shares purchased in parallel to the Delisting Offer, ams' shareholding in OSRAM has increased to 80.3%.
OSRAM’s listing on the Frankfurt Stock Exchange is expected to be terminated as of 30 June 2021 and the listing on the Munich Stock Exchange will be terminated as of 30 September 2021. The settlement of the Delisting Offer is expected for 30 June 2021.
“We have achieved our objective for the Delisting Offer which was to streamline the corporate structure, and we have also added meaningfully to our shareholding in OSRAM,” said Alexander Everke, CEO of ams OSRAM. “We are excited about the future prospects of ams OSRAM and look forward to continuing our successful integration to deliver on our strategic vision to create the uncontested leader in optical solutions.”
27 May 2021
ISRA and Atlas Copco conclude strategic partnership: Squeeze out completed
ISRA entered into a strategic partnership with the Swedish industrial group, Atlas Copco, in 2020. Atlas Copco's public offer to acquire all ISRA shares was initiated on February 10, 2020, and carried out on June 24, 2020. In addition, the Annual General Meeting of ISRA VISION AG resolved to exclude the remaining minority shareholders on December 15, 2020. This will end the stock exchange listing of ISRA VISION AG, which was last listed as a member of the SDAX and TecDAX.
Hosting the headquarters of the independent Machine Vision Solutions Division in Atlas Copco's Industrial Technique business unit, the company continues to operate under the name ISRA VISION AG with the same members of the Executive Board and Supervisory Board. For the employees, who were legally transferred to the parent company in the course of the merger, this strategic partnership offers a long-term perspective. Customers and business partners in particular will benefit from the stronger global presence of the Group. Cooperation with other Atlas Copco companies will be intensified in the future, with ISRA being an important pillar for the future strategy in the area of smart automation and digitalization.
Company profile
ISRA VISION AG, together with its subsidiaries, is worldwide leading in surface inspection of web materials. Furthermore, it is one of the globally leading providers of machine vision programs, specialising in the area of 3D machine vision, in particular for "3D robot vision".
The core competence of the Company is the ISRA-BrainWARE(R), an innovative software for intelligent machine vision systems. Here, the scientific know-how from the fields of optics, lighting technology, surveying technology, physics, image processing and classification algorithms and a complex system design are combined. Machine vision is a key technology for visualising systems that imitate the human eye. Today's ISRA applications focus primarily on the automation of production and quality assurance of goods and products supplied to large, future-oriented markets such as energy, healthcare, food, mobility and information. The customers mainly include renowned global players from the respective sectors. With more than 25 locations worldwide, ISRA offers customer proximity everywhere and ensures optimum service and support.
Further information is available at www.isravision.com.